Pretend Play in Italian Children: Validation of the Affect in Play Scale-Preschool Version
Diana Mabilia2015, Journal of Child and Family Studies
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Abstract
Despite the emerging literature supporting the central role of pretend play for children's cognitive, affective and social development, there is a paucity of standardized and validated measures devoted to assess it, especially for preschoolers. In addition, most of the existing tools failed in their attempt to assess the interplay among the different developmental domains which are involved in playing activities. The Affect in Play Scale-Preschool version is a semi-structured measure to assess cognitive and affective pretend play processes in children aged 4-5 using a 5-min standardized play task. This study was aimed to evaluate the construct and external validity of the scale in a sample of Italian preschoolers. A multi-group factor analysis confirmed the adequacy of the two-factor model with cognitive and affective factor for both 4-and 5-year-old children. No differences were found between boys and girls whereas older children reported higher play abilities. Correlations between pretend play, divergent thinking, teacher's measures of temperament and prosocial behavior were carried out. Results supported the use of APS-P as a valid tool for assessing the interplay of cognitive and affective abilities in Italian children.
Related papers
The Affect in Play Scale: Confirmatory Factor Analysis in Elementary School Children
Psychological Reports, 2011
The aim of this paper was to study the construct validity of the Affect in Play Scale, an empirically based measure of pretend play, in a group of 519 Italian children ages 6 to 10 years. In confirmatory factor analysis, a correlated two-factor structure with a cognitive and an affective factor was identified. Possible differences in factor scores by sex and age were investigated but no significant differences were found.
The Impact of Pretend Play on Children's Development: A Review of the Evidence
Pretend play has been claimed to be crucial to children's healthy development. Here we examine evidence for this position versus 2 alternatives: Pretend play is 1 of many routes to positive developments (equifinality), and pretend play is an epiphenomenon of other factors that drive development. Evidence from several domains is considered. For language, narrative, and emotion regulation, the research conducted to date is consistent with all 3 positions but insufficient to draw conclusions. For executive function and social skills, existing research leans against the crucial causal position but is insufficient to differentiate the other 2. For reasoning, equifinality is definitely supported, ruling out a crucially causal position but still leaving open the possibility that pretend play is epiphenomenal. For problem solving, there is no compelling evidence that pretend play helps or is even a correlate. For creativity, intelligence, conservation, and theory of mind, inconsistent correlational results from sound studies and nonreplication with masked experimenters are problematic for a causal position, and some good studies favor an epiphenomenon position in which child, adult, and environment characteristics that go along with play are the true causal agents. We end by considering epiphenomenalism more deeply and discussing implications for preschool settings and further research in this domain. Our take-away message is that existing evidence does not support strong causal claims about the unique importance of pretend play for development and that much more and better research is essential for clarifying its possible role.
The Impact of Teacher-Directed and Child-Directed Pretend Play on Cognitive Competence in Kindergarten Children
2003
The goal of our research was to study different forms of organization of pretend play on children's cognitive performance in a mixed-age environment. We studied two forms of management of the playing process: (a) teacher-directed play with simultaneous involvement of all children in the classroom, where the teacher plays the dominant role in the education process directing children's activity, and (b) child-directed play in various small groups. Twenty-six observations were performed on 51 children in two mixed-age classrooms. The mean age of the children was 4.6 years, with age span from 3 to 6 years. Data were collected regarding children's affective and cognitive behavior according to generally accepted taxonomies: Bloom for the cognitive domain, and Krathwohl for affective domain. We found a significant increase in cognitive manifestations during direction of the playing process in groups compared with frontal management of the lesson (113.1 ± 12.1 vs. 45.7 ± 10.3, mean ± SEM, p < 0.0001), which is related with better employment of the powerful education engine of the free-play children.
From Research to Clinical Settings: Validation of the Affect in Play Scale – Preschool Brief Version in a Sample of Preschool and School Aged Italian Children
Frontiers in Psychology
Affect in Play Scale-Preschool (APS-P) is one of the few standardized tools to measure pretend play. APS-P is an effective measure of symbolic play, able to detect both cognitive and affective dimensions which classically designated play in children, but often are evaluated separately and are scarcely integrated. The scale uses 5 min standardized play task with a set of toys. Recently the scale was extended from 6 to 10 years old and validated in Italy preschool and school-aged children. Some of the main limitations of this measure are that it requires videotaping, verbatim transcripts, and an extensive scoring training, which could compromise its clinical utility. For these reasons, a Brief version of the measure was developed by the original authors. This paper will focus on an APS-P Brief Version and its Extended Version through ages (6-10 years), which consists "in vivo" coding. This study aimed to evaluate construct and external validity of this APS-P Brief Version and its Extended Version in a sample of 538 Italian children aged 4-to-10 years. Confirmatory factor analysis yielded a two correlated factor structure including an affective and a cognitive factor. APS-P-BR and its Extended Version factor scores strongly related to APS-P Extended Version factor scores. Significant relationships were found with a divergent thinking task. Results suggest that the APS-P-BR and its Extended Version is an encouraging brief measure assessing pretend play using toys. It would easily substitute the APS-P and its Extended Version in clinical and research settings, reducing time and difficulties in scoring procedures and maintaining the same strengths.
What Do We Know about Pretend Play and Narrative Development? A Response to Lillard, Lerner, Hopkins, Dore, Smith, and Palmquist on "The Impact of Pretend Play on Children's Development: A Review of the Evidence
American Journal of Play, 2013
An article by Angeline S. Lillard and others in the January 2013 issue of Psychological Bulletin comprehensively reviewed and criticized the existing body of research on pretend play and children's development. Nicolopoulou and Ilgaz respond specifically to the article's critical review of research on play and narrative development, focusing especially on its assessment of research-mostly conducted during the 1970s and 1980s-on play-based narrative interventions. The authors consider that assessment overly negative and dismissive. On the contrary, they find this research strong and valuable, offering some solid evidence of beneficial effects of pretend play for narrative development. They argue that the account of this research by Lillard and her colleagues was incomplete and misleading; that their treatment of relevant studies failed to situate them in the context of a developing research program; and that a number of their criticisms were misplaced, overstated, conceptually problematic, or all of the above. They conclude that this research-while not without flaws, gaps, limitations, unanswered questions, and room for improvement-offers more useful resources and guidance for future research than Lillard and her colleagues acknowledged. Key words: narrative skills; pretend play and child development; research assessments Angeline S. Lillard and her coauthors (2013a) have produced a comprehensive critical review of research about the effects of pretend play on various dimensions of children's cognitive, linguistic, and socio-emotional development. This article has already generated some useful discussion (in the commentaries that accompanied it), and it will undoubtedly have a significant impact on a wide range of ongoing debates about the role of play in children's development 55
Criteria Used to Categorize Children's Play: Preliminary Findings
Social Behavior and Personality: an international journal, 2002
Debate exists about the defining characteristics of play, yet there have been few empirical studies to assess the reliability of existing categorizations. This preliminary study aimed to identify and assess the reliability of criteria generated by participants themselves to categorize children's play. Twelve participants (6F/6M), who were experienced in observing children's play, were shown eight video excerpts of children's play and asked questions to elicit (a) the criteria they used to categorize play and (b) the features of each play episode that were salient to the participants. Results showed that participants categorized play according to a mixture of Behavioral (Positive Affect; Nonliterality; Unrestrained/Unrestricted); Motivational (Practice; Communication and Cooperation) and Contextual (Presence of toys and props) criteria. These criteria were mostly comparable with existing criteria used to categorize play. Results are discussed in terms of the multidimensio...
Validation of the Revised Knox Preschool Play Scale for the Brazilian Population
Occupational Therapy International, 2019
Background. Play is essential to child development, and its evaluation is considered valid to indicate the stage of development of the child and indicate possible lagging. The Revised Knox Preschool Play Scale (RKPPS) provides an evolving description of the typical play behavior of preschool children, in six-month periods from zero to three years of age and then in annual periods up to six years of age. The RKPPS has already undergone the process of cultural adaptation for use in the Brazilian population, and it is necessary to analyze its applicability. Aims. To verify the reliability and internal consistency of the RKPPS for Brazilian children. Method. 135 children participated in the study, divided into different age groups with 15 in each group, and were filmed during free play in school or home contexts. Two independent raters evaluated the footage from two different times. Based on these evaluations, a statistical analysis was carried out in order to ascertain the reliability and the internal consistency of the Brazilian version of the RKPPS. Results. Intra-and interrater reliability showed a predominance of near-perfect to moderate agreement; however, some dimensions of certain age groups presented reasonable to poor agreement. The internal consistency was found to be satisfactory for most of the items evaluated; however, there were items with poor results in some dimensions of certain age groups. Conclusions. There is a need for further analysis of these items by a committee of experts to ensure the reproducibility of the instrument.
Children's Play and Development
Early Childhood Education From an Intercultural and Bilingual Perspective
Play expresses that human beings use activity as the most natural and adaptive way to be in the world. However, children's play had not been a subject of study and theoretical reflection until the beginning of the last century. Fortunately, the spread of developmental and educational psychology has been little by little sensitive to this extraordinary and original activity and the observation, study, and analysis of play have advanced a lot; the scientific development on play advances through the creation of very interesting theories based on the psychodevelopmental nature of play. In addition, in the last decades, an important number of authors stand up for a critical look at the general interpretation according to which children's play is just an enjoyable and relaxing activity: an activity of interest, per se, that plays an essential role in children's cognitive development and creative thinking. Both interpretations are considered in this chapter.
Social pretend play and social interaction in preschoolers
Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 1988
Social interaction was observed during social pretend play and nonpretend activities to determine whether positive and mature social behaviors were differentially associated with the pretend context. A within-subjects design and a semistructured play setting were used to control for individual differences, child and environmental effects. Thirty-seven 4-and 5-yearoold children were observed in groups of four for 47.5 minutes, in a series of play sessions. Their interactions within social pretend play and social nonpretend activities were.observed and compared. The results indicated that during pretend play, children's social interactions were more enjoyable, lasted longer, involved larger groups, and showed more play involvement and greater reciprocity. The results substantiate prior theoretical and empirical work which highlights the educational significance of social pretend play in early childhood. Social pretend play appears to provide a contextual framework within which mature social interaction can occur and social competencies may be acquired.
Related papers
THE ROLE OF PLAY IN CHILD ASSESSMENT AND INTERVENTION EDITED BY : Silvia Salcuni, Claudia Mazzeschi and Claudia Capella PUBLISHED IN : Frontiers in Psychology Lausanne: Frontiers Media. doi: 10.3389/978-2-88945-259-0
Mother–Infant and Extra-dyadic Interactions with a New Social Partner: Developmental Trajectories of Early Social Abilities during Play, 2017
Teaching to play performing a main role – effective method of pretend play facilitation in preschool-age children
We compared the efficiency of teacher's direct and indirect intervention into pretend play. Three hundred sixty-eight kindergarten children and 92 qualified kindergarten teachers were involved in the study. In the control group, a teacher indirectly initiated a play, creating a playing corner adjusted to the theme of the pretend play and during three consecutive days indirectly managed pretend play unobtrusively intervening into the playing process in accordance with actual situation needs. In an experimental group, a teacher during the first day actively initiated pretend play and directly conducted its course performing the main role in accordance with the predefined scenario and during the next two consecutive days indirectly managed the playing process as in the control group. In the experimental group, a statistically significant prevalence of the cognitively complex indicators of the children's playing activity was found suggesting pretend-play demonstration to be an effective facilitation instrument.
The role of pretend play in children's cognitive development
Early years education: major themes in education, 2006
Noting that there is a growing body of evidence supporting the many connections between cognitive competence and high-quality pretend play, this article defines the cluster of concepts related to pretend play and cognition, and briefly synthesizes the latest research on the role of such play in children's cognitive, social, and academic development. The article notes that there is growing evidence to suggest that high-quality pretend play is an important facilitator of perspective taking and later abstract thought, that it may facilitate higher-level cognition, and that there are clear links between pretend play and social and linguistic competence. The article also notes that there is still a great need for research on the relationship between high-quality pretend play and development of specific academic skills. The article concludes with a discussion of the challenges and potential policy directions suggested by the research findings. (Contains 44 references.
Analyzing The Relationships between Preschool Children’s Play Skills and Their Social Competence and Emotion Regulation Skills/Analiza odnosa između vještina igre i društvenih sposobnosti i vještine reguliranja emocija u predškolske djece
Croatian Journal of Education - Hrvatski časopis za odgoj i obrazovanje, 2018
Developing effective social and emotional skills is an important aspect of development in all children, and children's play skills are in constant interaction with their social and emotional competence. The aim of this research is to examine the relationship between preschool children's play skills and their social competence and emotion regulation skills. Tools used in this study are Revised Knox
The Dynamics of Pretend Play Development in Early Childhood
The phenomenon of play is constantly raising many questions for researchers and practitioners. Why is play important, what kind of play should be promoted in kindergarten classrooms, should it be supported and how? This article provides a short analysis on the concept of play and introduces an investigation aimed at analyzing the dynamics of the development of children's pretend play in early childhood settings. This research is performed within the framework of Cultural-Historical theory of play. The development of children's pretend play in ECEC groups will be discussed; gender differences and the level of pretend play within different age groups of children will be analyzed.
Pretend play in pre-schoolers: Need for structured and free play in pre-schools
South African Journal of Childhood Education, 2022
Background: Pretend play is a form of play that involves nonliteral actions. There are limited studies reporting the developmental trends of pretend play behaviours of typically developing pre-schoolers. This knowledge would be beneficial in the early identification of deviations in pre-schoolers who have or are at risk of developing developmental disabilities.Aim: The present study aimed to describe the developmental trends in pretend play skills across different age groups of pre-schoolers. The study also aimed to understand the differential patterns in pretend play observed across the Free Play and Structured Toy Play scenarios.Setting: This study was conducted on pre-schoolers in a classroom of the school.Method: The study followed a cross-sectional study design. Forty-eight participants were recruited for the study and were divided into four groups. A video recording of the child’s pretend play skills was recorded using a Sony-HDRCX405 camcorder in Free Play and Structured Toy ...
Cross-Cultural Adaptation and Reliability of Child-Initiated Pretend Play Assessment (ChIPPA)
Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy, 2011
Background. Play is an indication of a children's development. Purpose. Organize a culturally adapt the Child-Initiated Pretend Play Assessment to Brazilian population. Method. Translation and cultural adaptation procedures consisted of translation, synthesis, back translation, author's approval, and pretest of the assessment. For the pretest, 14 typically developing children were assessed. Was evaluated the use of play materials, duration of the assessment, and reliability. Findings. Play materials and duration of the assessment were appropriate for Brazilian children. Analysis of intra-rater reliability showed good agreement ranging from 0.90 to 1.00. Inter-rater reliability showed good to moderate agreement for five items ranging from 0.76 to 0.59. Four items showed chance to poor agreement (rho = −0.13 to 0.50). Implications. Results of the pretest indicate the Brazilian version of the ChIPPA is potentially useful for Brazilian children. ChIPPA training in Portuguese in ...
Pretend Play and the Development of Emotion Regulation in Preschool Children
Early Child Development and Care, 2001
Children's pretend play has been proposed as a mode of social interaction that enhances the development of emotion regulation ability. It was hypothesized that children who demonstrated adaptive emotion regulation in pretend play and/or engaged in pretend play with parents would be more proficient at emotion regulation in a wider context. Forty-seven pre-school boys and girls, aged 4 to 5 years, and their parents participated. Emotion regulation was assessed in a pretend play context using a negatively valenced event designed to elicit a high level of arousal. Children's responses were categorized according to successfully continuing pretend play and effectively resolving conflict. Children's success in continuing pretend play was related to emotion regulation skills in other contexts, whereas their effectiveness at resolving conflict was not. Children who engaged in pretend play frequently, and who did so with caregivers, had higher ratings of emotion regulation. This study provides some support for the relationship between pretend play and emotion regulation, and emphasizes the need for further research to examine the effects of parent-child pretend play interaction on the development of emotion regulation skills.
The impact of social pretend play on preschoolers’ social development: Results of an experimental study
Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 2023
This controlled intervention study with a pre-test, post-test, and follow-up design investigated whether promoting children’s social pretend play quality fosters their social development. Twenty-seven Swiss playgroups (N = 211 children, age: M = 43.3 months, SD= 6.5, with a median of 7 children per group) were randomly assigned to one of three experimental conditions: Play tutoring, provision of role play material, or control. Standardized tests and educator questionnaires were used to assess children’s social pretend play competence and social-cognitive, emotional and social skills as well as their peer relationship quality. Latent change models indicated that children’s social pretend play competence, behavioral skills, and positive peer relationships as reported by their educators increased most strongly for children in the play tutoring condition. No significant intervention effects emerged regarding children’s social-cognitive or emotional skills. The results show that actively promoting children’s social pretend play quality also fosters their social behavior and peer relationships.
What Do We Know About Pretend Play and Narrative Development?: A Response to Lillard, Lerner, Hopkins, Dore, Smith, & Palmquist on "The Impact of Pretend Play on Children's Development: A Review of the Evidence"
American Journal of Play 6:1 (Fall 2013), pp. 55-81.
An article by Angeline S. Lillard and others in the January 2013 issue of Psychological Bulletin comprehensively reviewed and criticized the existing body of research on pretend play and children's development. Nicolopoulou and Ilgaz respond specifically to the article's critical review of research on play and narrative development, focusing especially on its assessment of research-mostly conducted during the 1970s and 1980s-on play-based narrative interventions. The authors consider that assessment overly negative and dismissive. On the contrary, they find this research strong and valuable, offering some solid evidence of beneficial effects of pretend play for narrative development. They argue that the account of this research by Lillard and her colleagues was incomplete and misleading; that their treatment of relevant studies failed to situate them in the context of a developing research program; and that a number of their criticisms were misplaced, overstated, conceptually problematic, or all of the above. They conclude that this research-while not without flaws, gaps, limitations, unanswered questions, and room for improvement-offers more useful resources and guidance for future research than Lillard and her colleagues acknowledged. Key words: narrative skills; pretend play and child development; research assessments Angeline S. Lillard and her coauthors (2013a) have produced a comprehensive critical review of research about the effects of pretend play on various dimensions of children's cognitive, linguistic, and socio-emotional development. This article has already generated some useful discussion (in the commentaries that accompanied it), and it will undoubtedly have a significant impact on a wide range of ongoing debates about the role of play in children's development 55
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.