Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Elliott West — Growing Up in Twentieth-Century America

1998, Histoire Sociale-social History

Abstract

arguing somewhat contradictorily that women were either by nature incapable of learning or, once educated, would become so empowered that they would constitute a major threat to the social fabric of the nation. At the other end were those very articulate men, like the Rev. Thomas Webster, who called for the complete equality of men and women, not only in education, but in life itself. Between them were the defenders of separate education and coeducation in various forms. All of these arguments, it is interesting to note, relied heavily upon the metaphor of the family to explain and defend their positions -a fact that should caution those historians who define the relationship between gender and religion very narrowly and are quick to take all metaphors at face value. The second issue is the powerful role played by the state in the history of women's education within the Methodist Church. Drawing upon the work of Robert Gidney, Wyn Millar, and Bruce Curtis, the author is able to document how a rich diversity of educational experiments was drawn over time into a system of secondary and post-secondary institutions and how the character of this system was largely determined by the enormous power of the educational bureaucracy of the provincial state. In effect, even in an area of education that purposely set itself apart from the public system, the "Godless" state was able to impose its will and eventually make these experiments conform to its own goals and objectives. The third theme is purposefully political and should be taken as an object lesson by all those who are deeply concerned about the place of women within the university. If the traditional story line in the history of education is one of progress and inclusion -carrying an ever brighter lamp of learning to more and more people -Johanna Selles shows that the history of higher education for women in the Methodist Church has been one of continual struggle in the face of persistent (although by no means universal) opposition. Women were excluded from college and struggled hard to get back in; even as their presence in the university grew, they found that their claim to a place of their own was contested all the more strongly. Given recent events, I see no reason to believe that the same theme does not continue to inform the history of the education of women.